The Colorado Civil Rights Division recently ruled that Azucar Bakery in Denver
did not engage in illegal discrimination when it refused to make cakes with anti-gay messages on them.
In March of 2014, Marjorie Silva, owner of Azucar,
refused to make cakes
that included two Bible verses: “God hates sin. Psalm 45:7″ and
“Homosexuality is a detestable sin. Leviticus 18:2[2].” The cake design
was also to include a portrayal of two grooms holding hands in front of a
cross with a red “X” over them. The man who made the request, one
William Jack, proceeded to file a complaint against her for
discriminating against him based on his “creed” as defined by Colorado
law.
A decision letter from the Division ruled in Silva’s favor. She did
not discriminate against Jack because of his religious identity, but
because his request included “derogatory language and imagery.” Her
standard against such language is consistent across protected classes.
“In the same manner [she] would not accept [an order from] anyone
wanting to make a discriminatory cake against Christians, [she] will not
make one that discriminates against gays,” the decision reads. “The
evidence demonstrates that [Silva] would deny such requests to any
customer, regardless of creed.”
As UCLA Law Professor Eugene Volokh
predicted,
Colorado law protects discrimination against people based on their
belonging to certain classes, not based on their ideas and messages.
Consistency is a factor to assessing this, which is why Silva won, but another Colorado baker, Jack Phillips,
lost his case
when he refused to bake a wedding cake for a same-sex couple. Phillips
never even gave the couple a chance to discuss the artistry of the cake;
despite selling wedding cakes to different-sex couples, he refused to
sell the same product to same-sex couples. Though he argued that his
religious beliefs simply forbade him from “participating” in a same-sex
wedding, Administrative Law Judge Robert Spencer found that this was
just a pretext for anti-gay discrimination. “Only same-sex couples
engage in same-sex weddings,” he wrote. “Therefore, it makes little
sense to argue that refusal to provide a cake to a same-sex couple for
use at their wedding is not ‘because of’ their sexual orientation.”
READ MORE